Have you ever sat in on a Sunday message at a New Thought community and found the message stale and just not speaking to you?

Now, this is not a knock on my friends and fellow ministers, they usually do a great job and give an inspiring message.  It’s just hard to give a message that consistently meets the vast variety of needs of a spiritually diverse audience. The typical talk in most New Thought communities (with a few exceptions) by necessity has to speak to the majority of people, which means not necessarily everyone.  Why is this?

The answer lies in what each of us are currently seeking on our spiritual path.  Is it advice on how to use the tools of New Thought wisdom to navigate the practical material life or is it guidance on how to transcend the material as we evolve our way towards the mystical?  Most New Thought groups focus on the former in an attempt to meet their attendees “where they are” (or better said, “where they think they are”). Hence, those seeking support in self transcendence may find little that speaks to them.

Therein lays an issue that has faced spiritual and religious groups for thousands of years, most people who walk in the door seeking comfort and support are looking for ways of dealing with and finding meaning in their physical lives while the deepest teaching those traditions have to offer is about actually transcending that physical life altogether.  Most folks are not ready for that.

The juggling act that a spiritual community has to do is to present simultaneously different messages for different needs, one for the human side of their members, one for the spiritual side.  This balance needs to be created in New Thought groups with conscious intention.  Yes, speak to those suffering and give them tools to move through their earthy challenges.  Yet, also speak to those who are seeking to shift their consciousness to higher vibratory levels and to seek communion with the Divine.  Is your group doing what it can to meet the needs of all seekers?

Spiritual Beings/Material Experience

OK, let’s back up a minute and remind ourselves of some key spiritual truths.  First, we are spiritual beings having this human experience.  Inherent in that is the fact that we live in multiple planes of existence simultaneously.

Our ultimate truth comes from a “higher” spiritual plane of which for most people we may occasionally only get glimpses. This spiritual plane is of the Absolute, the realm of the timeless, where there is no form only non-dual unity and Oneness. This realm is the direction in which our spiritual evolution is headed.

However, most of our day to day focus and attention is on a human plane of time and space where everything is in relationship with one another.  Our existence here is driven by the belief in duality and all of the stories of the interactions between these separate “things”. Our stories are frequently full of drama and unmet needs that demand our attention.

Although there are infinite vibratory levels of existence and experience between the world of form and the world of Spirit, the most relevant for us in most cases is the plane of mind. This is noted by our use of consciousness and free will choice to either turn our attention and energy (and intention) “upwards” to Spirit or “downward” to the physical world.  Which realm is directing our focus?

New Thought as Translation

Most people who seek religious or spiritual support are driven by the perceived needs of the human realm.  Historically, this has been a spiritual group’s biggest “customer base”.  Most spiritual groups created content to meet this need.  For most of time in the traditional faiths of our history, this content was the “exoteric” or outer teachings given to the masses.

Philosopher Ken Wilber describes this function thusly:

“It acts as a way of creating meaning for a separate self; if offers myths and stories and tales and narratives and rituals and revivals that, taken together, help the separate self make sense of and endure the slings and arrows of outrageous fortune.  This function of religion does not usually or necessarily change the level of consciousness in a person; it does not deliver radical transformation.”

Wilber refers to this function of religion as “translation”, as the spiritual message is directed towards giving the person a unique way to think and feel about this material reality. Here the spiritual path “translates” the material world in a new way for the seeker so they may better deal with the challenges they face in the material world.

For example, the “laws” of the Old Testament, the Ten Commandments and many of the morally interpretive stories of the Bible can be seen as offering the reader guidance on primarily living in the material world.  The sermons and teachings of ministers through the ages have stressed how to be and act in this physical world. Yes, the spiritual realm was referenced but the emphasis was on how to live right here, right now.

New Thought has done a lot to focus on “translating the world” for its followers.  The catch phrase most associated with the Science of Mind is “change your thinking, change your life”.  The life being changed in most folks’ imagination is that physical, material life.

Ernest Holmes’ early radio show began with a booming announcer voice proclaiming “there is a power for good in the universe and you can use it!”  And, how did we imagine we were going to use that power?  For most folks, they imagined things in the realm of form…..new cars, relationships, jobs, wealth, power and the like.

In the early 2000s, along came the cultural sensation of the movie and the book, The Secret.  It popularized New Thought ideas and that popularity was anchored in the acquiring of physical “stuff”. Create that vision board and say those affirmations and get everything (material) that your heart desires.

Now, New Thought methods for changing our thoughts to change our physical reality can and do work if applied appropriately and consistently.  The issue, in my opinion, comes from exclusively focusing on them as a tool to material manifestation when there is a deeper and more meaningful path awaiting you. Yes, for most people, we need to have certain human needs met before we can be “free” to pursue those higher spiritual ones.  But too often our teachings do not move that individual to those ultimate pursuits, instead staying comfortably in the area of manifesting more material things.

I have long noticed that there are generally speaking three groups of new seekers who come into New Thought communities.  All three groups are seeking something (material or spiritual) from life.  The first group tries out (to a limited degree) New Thought’s “change your thinking” tools to help them and decides that they are a bunch of bull and leaves.  The second group tries out the tools, finds they helped them meet their immediate need and then leaves (but at least satisfied!).  The final group tries out the New Thought tools, finds they helped them and then wants to go deeper with them.  This group wants to use the tools to find spiritual meaning, to awaken, to transform their lives.

There is a four step path for changing consciousness that is taught in many New Thought groups.  The first step is where we see things done “to me”, that we are victims of this outer world, buffeted about by forces beyond our control.  Most folks who come to New Thought struggling with the material world are at this level of consciousness. The initial goal is to move the person beyond this step.

Most of the change your thinking “translation” type teachings of New Thought are directed towards this person shifting their consciousness and taking responsibility for their part in life by seeing life as being created “by me”.  That is changing their perspective from seeing themselves as a victim to the forces of the world to their having agency and control over their lives.  Life “out there” doesn’t control me; instead I control life “out there”.  However, the focus, even at this stage is usually on life “out there”, material life.

In a sense, spirituality that focuses on translating how we look at the physical world so that we can better handle living in our “humanness” relates to growth only on the human plane, it is horizontal in direction only.  I’m not knocking it. It is good work. It is necessary. It is important to our growth. It must be done to prepare us for the vertical leap in consciousness that is calling us.

New Thought as Transformation

In the past, rarer were those people who sought religious or spiritual support driven by their needs emerging from the spiritual realm.  Recognizing that most people were neither ready for nor would understand their deepest teachings, most of these spiritual or religious groups limited access to these teachings to only the most serious students.  This content was the “esoteric” or mystical teachings given to only a few.

However in current times, there are many more people seeking out these teachings.  The rise in the numbers of people labeling themselves “spiritual but not religious” is indicative of the increase in the percentage of the population who seek to create their own relationship with a transcendent power. Hence, more and more people coming in the doors of all spiritual communities, especially in New Thought, are seeking this vertical path.

Philosopher Ken Wilber describes this function in this manner:

“[This second aspect of religion has served] the function of radical transformation and liberation.  This function of religion does not separate the self, but utterly shatters it –not consolation but devastation, not entrenchment but emptiness, not complacency but explosion, not comfort but revolution –in short, not a conventional bolstering of consciousness but a radical transmutation and transformation at the deepest seat of consciousness itself.”

Wilber refers to this function of religion as “transformation”, as the spiritual message changes from one that is about a separate “self” understanding and better relating to material reality to a new message that totally breaks down our sense of being a “separate self” navigating a “material reality”.  It shatters that ego driven view of reality.

In our role as “transformation agents”, we assist all in shifting their consciousness from seeing themselves as “self” to becoming “Self”.  We are no longer seen as individuals but rather “individualized” expressions of the One.  We may still be “in the world” but we are no longer “of the world”.

New Thought has much within its teachings that move us to the mystical side of life.  Most folks don’t see New Thought teaching’s transformational basis.  But it’s deeply there.

Why is it not recognized? I believe one major reason is that the basic “translational” material world messaging by New Thought has been so successful in the past that modern culture already simply accepts as true that thoughts have causative power.  I covered this in detail in another article entitled “Is New Thought Now Old Thought?” so I won’t retrace that ground here.  However, my point in bringing it up is that to the degree that someone has heard of New Thought and has some awareness of it, that will be connected solely to the message of “change your thinking, change your [material] life”.  That limited understanding of New Thought unfortunately relegates the philosophy as being solely about “positive thinking” and not “spiritual transformation”.

However, we can easily point to some of the “transformational” tools that New Thought teaches as a part of its tool kit.  Students are encouraged to have a routine spiritual practice as a part of their daily life.  This includes taking time for meditation, for affirmative prayer, for visioning and the like.  All of these are to grow a sense of the Divine in the person’s life, to cultivate a relationship with God or Spirit.

A key aspect of the teaching of New Thought begins with an awareness that everything is “One”.  Affirmative prayer when taught as “steps” has as the first two steps as “everything is One” and “that Oneness is in me”.  In other words, the steps of prayer are designed to cultivate a consciousness of unity with God or the Divine. I’m not saying that everyone who uses affirmative prayer has had the full experience of non-dual oneness, but the intention is certainly in that direction.

The writings of the founders of most New Thought groups are full of mystical insights that we can tap into as a part of our teaching.  New Thought’s roots are intertwined with the mystical teachings throughout the ages, from the Hermetic and Hellenic traditions and coming forward.  There are many transformative writings that can be cited, but only if we choose to do so.

I am fairly steeped in the teachings of Science of Mind founder, Ernest Holmes.  Almost all of his books have a mystical side to them if we set the intention to see it. Consider the The Holmes Papers books or his small volume entitled Your Invisible Power for examples.

For the past few years, I have served on the board of the Science of Mind Archives and taken on a role as one of their key researchers.  I have had the privilege in that role to listen to hundreds of hours of Holmes’ recordings.  His Sunday talks, his radio and TV shows, his phonograph recordings all could be seen (in the language I am using here) as “translational”.  He was primarily serving to help people navigate material life via this spiritual basis.  Yes, there was language that was deeper and more mystical in nature, but his key points were most often what you will still hear on a typical Sunday in a New Thought center today –how can you use this stuff to have a better life here and right now?

However, my research also led to the compilation of the book Ernest Holmes at Asilomar published in 2023.  One of the key insights I had in creating that book was that the messaging that Holmes gave to his followers at their summer conferences was the deep mystical truths that served as the foundation for his teaching.  He was able to go deeper into Science of Mind as a “transformational” teaching with that group of followers than at other times. My point is that if we choose to focus more on the transformational role in our New Thought teaching (and I am suggesting that we should), then there are many sources to support us.

A moment ago, I mentioned the four step path for changing consciousness that is taught in many New Thought groups.  However, I only mentioned the first two steps –we first see life as being done “to me” and then are taught to control our thoughts and actions so that we move to seeing life is being done “by me”.

If we stop there, then our work has been purely translational.  However, if we fully support students in moving to their personal experience of the last two steps, we are moving into the true transformative work that many seek.  Those further stages call us to see that life is being done or lived “through me” and ultimately “as me”.

The movement from “by me” to “through me” involves a deep spiritual surrender to the flow of life.  It is about letting go of the ego “me” that needs to control the world to a new level of awareness that I am simply in the magical flow of life and I don’t have to “control” everything.  This is a key spiritual step towards releasing attachment to form, to the individual self and to the material world.

The movement from “through me” to “as me” takes that release of the world of form to the next level and calls you to meld your consciousness into the consciousness of the universe, to see you as simply one divine life being lived as a part of the greater Divine Life.

Both of these steps are deeply transformational if learned and embodied by the student. It is this aspect of New Thought that I believe we need to ensure we are adequately supporting as we seek to meet the needs of our members who are seeking such breakthroughs.

New Thought as Translation & Transformation

So what is my intention with sharing these thoughts?  My desire is that you personally take a moment and evaluate your experience of New Thought, either as a teacher of the philosophy or one who attends a New Thought community, and ask yourself if the current teachings offered are meeting both the “translation” and “transformation” goals of students at different stages of their spiritual paths.  Are you doing both?  If so, is the mixture appropriate?

I want to stress that this is not an “either-or” type of thing but instead New Thought should be fostering both “translation” and “transformation”.  We must be teaching practical skills for navigating this wild material world we find ourselves, but we must also be encouraging and supporting each person’s spiritual evolution to the highest degree possible. We have great gifts in our teachings that can fulfill both needs and we should be consciously using them.

It’s important to remember that everyone, no matter where they are on their path, can benefit from support in the material world and be drawn at the right moment to leaps in consciousness.  The most spiritually advanced person can still get hit by the tragedies of material life and find themselves seeking worldly guidance and understanding.  Even the person who seems most attached to materiality can experience a breakthrough in awareness of Oneness.

We should also remember that “enlightenment” or “awakening” is not a place where you arrive and stay.  The true reality is that our awakening to Oneness is a continuous unfolding process.  No matter what spiritual experiences we can point to as “evidence” of our enlightenment and personal “arrival”, the process continues and continues ever up the spiral of life.  And, as mentioned, one can attain great awareness of non-dual reality but that doesn’t make them immune from the challenges of the material world.

True growth is coupled with a call to be of service to the One.  The more you become aware of the eternal Oneness of all of life, the more your heart opens to love to assist other expressions of the One to remember their truth. Our goal is not to transcend the world, but to transform our consciousness, to open our hearts to the power of love for all and to bring that heart power back to the material world.

So, again, If you are a New Thought teacher or part of a New Thought community, I would ask you to ponder if you are fostering both the tools to support successfully living in this world of form and to successfully support transcending it?  Where are there opportunities for improvement?  What am I or we going to do now?

One final note seems relevant in this moment. There seems to be at this time an overwhelming amount of worldly issues going on — from wars, to divisiveness, to a rise in a level of human “unkindness”.  It would be easy to spend all of our time and energy addressing these expressions of the material world that are popping up right now.  My advice in regards to this is to yes, address those worldly events that call to us personally.  Do so in our own way using our teachings as guideposts.  However, don’t focus so much of your time and energy on these things that you don’t have the bandwidth left in your (and our) mission towards growing and transcending this world. This is also an important part of both your teaching others and your own evolution.

I hope that you found this article thought provoking and allowed some “new thoughts” on this topic to emerge in your awareness. I would love to hear your thoughts in whatever  form you wish to share.

Love and light,

Mark

A Postscript

A quick extra note in case you are interested– I have taken a couple of the Holmes’ talks from Asilomar and created some content outlining some of the more esoteric points I felt he was making.

First, consider this 2 part article where I deconstruct what Holmes is saying in a talk from Asilomar in 1954 entitled “Discovering God”.   LINK TO PART ONE             LINK TO PART TWO

Second, here is a video from my YouTube channel where I break down some quotes from a Holmes’ talk at Asilomar in 1958 where he discusses affirmative prayer as a means of creating a new “time track”.      LINK TO VIDEO